BANNED
Yes, When We Were Magic Is Banned!
2 documented challenges
Why Was It Banned?
Where Was It Banned?
Read It Anyway
The best response to a book ban is reading the book. Here's where to get it:
Frequently Asked Questions
Is When We Were Magic banned?
Yes, When We Were Magic by Sarah Gailey has been banned or challenged in 2 documented instances across 2 states in the United States, including Tennessee, Texas. It remains one of the most frequently challenged books in America.
Why was When We Were Magic banned?
When We Were Magic has been challenged and banned for the following reasons: Sexual Content. These challenges have come from school boards, libraries, and parent groups seeking to restrict access to the book.
Where is When We Were Magic banned?
As of 2025, When We Were Magic has been banned or challenged in Tennessee, Texas. Notable bans include Collierville Schools (2022), North East Independent School District (2021).